I had a very similar experience in Atlanta,Ga. Took several pairs of True Religion and Rock Revial jeans in.
One pair still had the tags. If you know anything about these designers then you know they are VERY expensive, over $100. I wasn't expecting what I paid but I also wasn't expecting to be insulted. I was offered $20 for 2 pairs of the Rock Revial and told that my jeans, with the tags, were worn looking and dirty.
Nothing about either designer has a Dirty LOOK.
I was shocked!!! I said, "That's okay" and took all my items. Then several ladies and their kids walked out the store with me and asked if they could purchase them from me. They were willing to pay $65-$75 for one pair.
Shame on you Atlanta for not knowing your customers and insulting them as well.
NEVER waste your time trying to sell to Plato's Closet. They really have no fashion clue.
Reason of review: Poor customer service.
Preferred solution: Need better training and customer service.